Consignment jewelry · Cincinnati

Don't settle for less.

Most jewelry stores and pawn shops offer less than wholesale when they buy from you. Consign with us instead: we sell your piece at fair market value, and you receive the true value of your piece.

Free evaluationNo fees, no hasslesPaid in full at sale
Don't settle for less.
Our consignment process

It's as easy as One, Two, Three!

From the initial consultation to the final sale, the process is seamless and straightforward. Our goal is for every customer to leave the shop happy and satisfied knowing they received the full value of their cherished item.

STEP 01
Evaluation

Bring your jewelry to us for a free evaluation. Taylor will advise you on how much we can sell your piece for, making sure you receive the full value. We treat you like our vendor, because you are.

STEP 02
Listing

Once agreed, we list and advertise your jewelry for sale, in our cases, and online. We have many customers who would love your piece.

STEP 03
Receive your payment

After a successful sale, you are paid in full right away. Worth the wait: our clients receive the true value of their goods, not the low-ball sub-wholesale figure.

Types of jewelry accepted

If it is precious, bring it in.

Old engagement rings, inherited necklaces, loose stones, watches you no longer wear. See what we currently have in our cases on consignment.

Emerald and pink tourmaline double drop pendant
Rose gold ring with a cushion pink tourmaline
Consignment jewelry, explained

We sell your pieces on your behalf.

Do you have an old or unwanted engagement ring, necklace, earring, bracelet, luxury watch, or stone you want to consign? Taylor Healey Jewelry accepts jewelry on consignment, with the expertise to ensure you receive a fair price for your precious items.

Consignment means you (the consignor) give us (the consignee) the authority to sell your jewelry for an agreed value, instead of laboring to find a buyer all alone. Once sold, you are paid in full. Everyone wins: wanting sellers meet desired buyers, with fair prices shared by all.

We are a reputable jewelry shop and consignment store in Cincinnati committed to fair market value and a rewarding experience. If you have unused or unwanted jewelry, you will never regret consigning it with us.

Determining your jewelry's value

Determining your jewelry's value

We price consignment jewelry on current market trends, not wholesale value. Prices vary with brand, condition, age, materials, and rarity.

Your items carry sentimental value, and we strive to give you a fair price that reflects the current market, using reliable industry databases and expert appraiser valuation to price your jewelry accurately.

Marketing and sale

Marketing and sale

Bring us your item for an appraisal and we will give you an honest, fair price. Once agreed, we display it in our store, and upon sale we call you to receive your payment, or mail it for your convenience. Easy and hassle-free.

We leverage several channels to sell your item as quickly as possible: online, in-store, and through auctions. Typically you will get double what you would selling outright to a pawn shop or jewelry store.

Turn unused jewelry into cash, without fees or hassles.
Consign your jewelry today

Turn unused jewelry into cash, without fees or hassles.

At a professional jewelry consignment store you can receive the highest offer for your item. The process is fast, easy, and stress-free. If you are thinking of consigning your jewelry, schedule a consultation with us today.